No. 6, The precursors, December 2021
Book reviews
Eileen Gray: Una casa bajo el sol
Eileen Gray: A House Under the Sun
Being the precursor – a female precursor, in this case – in a given discipline is rarely a paved road. Rather, it is, everywhere, a tortuous path riddled with the potholes that come with leading a change or, at least, opening a door to a possible new world. When this happens in an environment reluctant to change and to whatever departs from the norm – as the architectural circles of the early part of the last century were – the situation becomes far more multifaceted and tortuous.
Precisely for this reason, undertaking a retrospective and introspective exploration of the life of a creator now recognised as pivotal in the recent History of Architecture seems less an option than an obligation. Doing so through the Ninth Art – that of comics – also makes it possible to generate a kind of non-linear discourse, in which one can move backwards and forwards in time, in order to present a story that explores the narrative possibilities of image and text.
This is what Charlotte Malterre-Barthes – the scriptwriter – and Zosia Dzierżawska – the illustrator – set out to do, and achieve, in this short book. Made up of six chapters, the comic traces the life of Eileen Gray, traditionally known as a ‘mere collaborator’ of Le Corbusier. Inevitably, the affront perpetrated by the Swiss architect at Villa E-1027 takes on considerable prominence, filling numerous pages, but at the same time the book offers an interesting journey through the life of the Irish-born architect. Her childhood and her relationship with her parents, James Maclaren Smith-Gray and Eveleen Smith-Gray; her training in lacquer work under Seizo Sugawara; her immersion in the intellectual Paris of the time, where she would form professional, emotional and romantic ties with figures from the worlds of film and art such as Natalie Barney, Berenice Abbott and Marie-Louise Damien ‘Damia’; and her association with Jean Badovici are central to a work which seeks, despite its apparent naivety, to delve deeply not only into Gray’s design principles but, above all, into her complex and solitary personality.
Both the drawing and the texts shun excess at all times and, through short sentences, simple strokes and flat fills of basic colours, they succeed both in capturing the reader’s attention and in creating page compositions that are thoroughly rich and beautiful and that often depart from the norm in the world of comics.
Eileen Gray: Una casa bajo el sol is, in short, a wager on eccentricity and on outcasts, on those – represented in the figure of Eileen Gray – who at some point chose to break with convention and who, for that reason, were cruelly relegated to the background. Above all, however, it is an opportunity for redemption, an act of justice that restores the architect to the place that is rightfully hers, and one that takes shape in a work accessible to all readers, specialist and lay alike, of any age.
How to cite
Pérez García, Alejandro. Review of Eileen Gray: Una casa bajo el sol, by Charlotte Malterre-Barthes and Zosia Dzierżawska; trans. Carlos Traspaderne. VAD. Veredes, arquitectura y divulgación, no. 6 (2021): 136.
© 2021 Alejandro Pérez García. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.