No. 5, The opportunities, June 2021

Architectural criticism

Junctures: What Are We Architects in Costa Rica Talking About?

Coyunturas: ¿De qué estamos hablando los arquitectos en Costa Rica?

The Costa Rican reality of recent years is not very different from that of other Latin American countries; in fact, it seems that we are watching the same film: a country adrift, divided, with neo-populist governments, corruption, political clientelism and the ever-present triumph of deception and post-truth.

The main difference in our film would be that everything other countries have already experienced is only now beginning to materialise here, but without the recurring “spoilers” ruining the imminent ending of this crude national production.

Thus we were living in an environment that was already one of omnipresent and imminent economic crisis, even before the COVID pandemic. So it gradually became clear to us that in times of crisis architecture was among the last things to be talked about; at least, the political debates of recent governments did not concern any urgent need for architectural works or, more generally, for infrastructure, except perhaps when, from time to time, more roads were proposed, apparently to pay homage to the car if it brings political dividends.

However, architecture is not alone in its absence from government policy; culture in general has been sidelined, especially since the declaration of the pandemic last year. In fact, culture and any of its expressions, such as literature, architecture or history, do not seem to be relevant in the current system, in which memory is systematically being lost in favour of a world of eternal present, something truly harmful for a profession that is really very recent in Costa Rica.

By way of context, by the mid-1930s the country had only six practising architects; later, in 1965, came the first organised professional body, the Asociación de Arquitectos, which was barely able to register because it could not reach the minimum of 25 professional members; and the first school of architecture has only just turned 50.

Before that school existed, Costa Rican architects trained mainly in Mexico, or had to travel to Brazil, the United States or Europe.

At present, despite having something like thirteen schools of architecture and some 4,000 graduate architects, we are far from matching the quality of the great works of the heroic period of the last century, all of which were produced by architects who had graduated abroad (Fig. 1).

Oblique aerial view of central San José: in the foreground, two office towers, one of grey concrete with projecting volumes and a red roof, the other lower with a façade of blue and ochre horizontal bands and a green roof; around them, a grid of regular blocks with low buildings with red, white and green roofs, streets with traffic and, below, the tree canopy of a park.
Figure 1. Aerial view of the city of San José, showing the system of regular blocks laid out in the colonial period, with the Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social (CCSS) buildings of 1966 and 1980 standing out. Photographer: architect Leonardo Chacón (2021), for this publication.

There is very little good architecture, good designs are insufficient, good projects are very scarce, and good architects can perhaps be counted on the fingers of two hands. And this is another thing architects in Costa Rica do not talk about.

Nor is architecture talked about in the publishing field, despite the hundreds of architecture theses that are produced and the research that the many university lecturers ought to carry out; publications of books specialising in architecture, or in architects, are meagre.

The dissemination of national architecture in professional publications is almost non-existent, since everything published in Costa Rica in a year, universities in Argentina or Mexico would publish in a month.

Nor do we architects talk about the lack of architectural competitions, or about the fact that the works are always carried out by the same companies, which win public tenders on the criteria of speed and low cost, not of quality, let alone of architecture. This results in public works that are irrelevant, characterless, bland and usually in poor taste. We architects also remain silent when some of the few buildings of architectural value are destroyed (Fig. 2). And this despite the fact that all these actions further ruin the natural landscape and that of our cities.

Façade of a former Art Deco cinema painted entirely bright red, with large white “SYR” signs and the remains of a metal advertising structure on top; on the left, a low building housing a fast-food restaurant and, on the right, a white two-storey neoclassical building with columns and balconies, under a clear blue sky; in front, a street with a few pedestrians.
Figure 2. Buildings facing the central park of San José, with the former Cine Palace (1933) by the architect Paul Ehrenberg (1900-1965), now converted into a second-hand clothing store (ropa americana). A few months ago an attempt was made to hide the building behind a gigantic advertisement, whose structure is still visible. On the right, the former Teatro Raventós (1927). Photographer: architect Luis Alberto Monge (2021), for this publication.

The national panorama was not always so bleak: this year Costa Rica will be marking just 200 years of independence, obtained in 1821 without asking for it, without fighting for it and even without wanting it.

Since then, however, governments focused on strengthening education and, with an economy based on exporting coffee to the major markets, forged a prosperous country and citizens who defended democratic institutions, which led them to abolish the army in 1948 and to popularise the “pura vida” identity that characterises us.

That was the great period, with a handful of architects; but now that there are thousands, only a few individual, disconnected efforts are emerging that seek to awaken the debate on architecture in the country (Fig. 3).

Black-and-white photograph taken from below: the curved fair-faced concrete edge of a helical staircase frames a ceiling of triangular concrete ribs, with spotlights lit in some of its coffers.
Figure 3. Detail of the triple-height space of the helical staircase of the Museo del Oro (1980). An underground building, the work of three of the most distinguished Costa Rican architects, and built during one of the worst economic crises: Jorge Borbón (1933-2018), Jorge Bertheau (1937-2020) and Edgar Vargas (1922-2007). Photographer: architect Luis Alberto Monge (2020).

For this small group, the pandemic becomes a unique opportunity to highlight the need for good architecture and good cities in order to overcome the health crisis.

It is time for us Costa Rican architects to raise our voices, reminding everyone that health and quality of life depend to a large extent on the architecture that surrounds us.

How to cite

Monge Calvo, Luis Alberto. “Coyunturas: ¿De qué estamos hablando los arquitectos en Costa Rica?” [Junctures: What Are We Architects in Costa Rica Talking About?]. VAD. Veredes, arquitectura y divulgación, no. 5 (2021): 108–110.

© 2021 Luis Alberto Monge Calvo. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.