No. 5, The opportunities, June 2021
Editorial
Opportunism
Oportunismo
Opportunities are slippery, like those fish that, even out of the water, refuse to become a catch, like the thief who has already vanished when we turn round patting our empty pocket. They are rare instants in which favourable circumstances converge so that, suddenly, everything seems possible. There is currently a certain consensus around the idea that every crisis carries an opportunity within it, but it is worth asking whether this conviction may not have been born among those who play with marked cards, among those with a tightrope walker’s vocation because they know that a safety net is stretched between them and the abyss.
No crisis – be it health-related, economic or of any other kind – is a sufficient condition for the possibility of doing things better to open up before us. Only if the appropriate means and a resolute will exist can a crisis be transformed into an opportunity not to repeat mistakes.
In the case of architecture, a crisis is not a necessary condition for an opportunity to arise either. Many of the works we now regard as canonical began as apparently trivial commissions or as the whim of a stubborn client. Sometimes excess, a caprice or a delirium conceals the possibility of blowing up what is taken for granted and exploring the limits of the discipline.
Only thus can we understand why the architecture books of the twentieth century fill their pages with a flower kiosk or with uninhabitable houses that celebrate the smoothness of their glass; only thus can we justify a visit to a small Olivetti shop hidden behind the ivory-coloured arcades of San Marco when nobody uses typewriters any more. Nor has the twenty-first century changed this rule of the game, judging by the significance that a tiny chapel in a remote German setting acquired at the hands of a Swiss master. Perhaps because, deep down, it has always been so, as Palladio demonstrated when he turned a Vicentine villa into an artifice capable of measuring itself against nature and condensing time.
On occasion, the opportunity even precedes the crisis. During the early years of the twentieth century, in a Europe that barely sensed what awaited it around the corner, a group of bellicose Italian artists invented their own catharsis: by proclaiming that a “roaring automobile” was “more beautiful than the Victory of Samothrace”1 they broke with every inherited ethical and aesthetic postulate. Led by the poet Filippo Tommaso Marinetti (Fig. 1), they signed the Futurist Manifesto in 1909. It was, in the end, the ephemeral dream of a radical avant-garde, buried beneath the rubble of the first Great War.

Ten years later, Marinetti himself drafted the Fascist Manifesto; in that young movement he sensed the definitive occasion to put an end to the Europe of the Ancien Régime. His error is a real wake-up call – still valid today – about how infamy often disguises itself as opportunity.
In the late twenties, Adalberto Libera was one of the group of architects linked to the Italian National Fascist Party. The author, among other works, of the Casa del Balilla in Civitanova Marche – a building of imposing sculptural force, at once naval and futurist – the architect somewhat reluctantly accepted the tiny commission of a man close to Benito Mussolini, the writer Curzio Malaparte.
The task was to build a house on a crag on the island of Capri. After visiting the site, Libera proposed a simple dwelling, an exercise in strict academic correctness that displeased his client, because Malaparte wanted – as he later wrote – a house that would be “the image of his nostalgia”.2
And, it seems, what he longed for was to sit on a horizontal plane stretching to the edge of the Mediterranean, to shelter from the winds behind a concrete sail and to frame, from inside his refuge, sea stacks on which perhaps one morning he thought he saw Parthenope; he probably also felt nostalgia for a flight of steps he often visited on his walks around the island of Lipari, accompanied by the faithful Febo, when his dissidence led to his being sentenced to exile by former party comrades (Fig. 2).

Curzio Malaparte scribbled his intentions over the plans drawn by Libera and transformed that nondescript project into a memorable work. Unlike the architect, the inhabitant perceived the scale of that opportunity.
Finally, there is also the possibility of mistaking for opportunity what are in fact merely siren songs. In such cases it is better to choose to tie ourselves to the mast and so avoid falling into temptations that would lead us to shipwreck. Let us think of the architects – some of unquestionable talent – who decades ago embraced the most banal aspects of postmodernism. Once the euphoria of the moment has passed, their legacy cannot bear today to face a mirror that returns to it the image of a disfigured old age.
History speaks of opportunities seized because it is generally written by those who have won. Stefan Zweig relates that the Turks of Sultan Mehmed II took Byzantium by entering through a small gate that the Christians had left open “through an incomprehensible oversight and precisely because it lacked the slightest importance”.3
By contrast, rarely does anyone mention those who let their opportunity slip when it knocked at their door, such as the film producer who decided to cancel the funding of Life of Brian because he considered it obscene.
And perhaps that is what genius consists in: knowing how to recognise opportunity when it passes under our noses, walking along calmly without attracting the attention of almost anyone.
Notes
- 1↩
The Futurist Manifesto was first published on 5 February 1909 in the Gazzetta dell’Emilia, although its best-known version is the one that appeared only fifteen days later in the French daily Le Figaro. Its fourth point reads: “…une automobile rugissante, qui a l’air de courir sur de la mitraille, est plus belle que la Victoire de Samothrace”.
El Universo Futurista. 1909-1936. MART Collection. Museo di Arte Moderna e Contemporanea di Trento e Rovereto, Italy. Available at http://proa.org/esp/exhibition-el-universo-futurista-manifiestos.php#1 (last accessed: June 2021).
- 2↩
“Oggi vivo in un’isola, in una casa triste, dura severa sul mare: una casa che è lo spettro, l’immagine segreta della prigione. L’immagine della mia nostalgia”. The extract belongs to the story La Passeggiata, a text included – among others – in the volume Opere Complete di Curzio Malaparte (Firenze, Vallecchi editore, 1959, 2ª edizione).
- 3↩
In his work Momentos estelares de la humanidad (Barcelona, ed. Acantilado, 2016, 22nd reprint), Stefan Zweig includes a chapter entitled “La conquista de Bizancio” (The Conquest of Byzantium); in the subchapter “Kerkaporta, la puerta olvidada” (Kerkaporta, the Forgotten Gate) he explains how this oversight enabled the Ottoman troops to complete the capture of the city.
How to cite
López Cotelo, Borja Ramón. “Oportunismo” [Opportunism]. VAD. Veredes, arquitectura y divulgación, no. 5 (2021): 12–15.
© 2021 Borja Ramón López Cotelo. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.