No. 4, The secondary characters, December 2020
Architectural criticism
Emilio Moya Lledós, Conservation Architect of the Republic
Emilio Moya Lledós, arquitecto conservador de la República
The initiative to publish the secondary characters is most welcome. After several years studying little-publicised architecture, I have always thought that the history of architecture was overlooking architects from whom there was much to learn, as excellent as those who have been widely, and at times repetitively, publicised. Among the reasons for this situation, I believe the main one is the lack of culture of an overly simplifying and hasty society; but it also has to do with the secondary characters themselves, who were more concerned with their architectural practice than with their biography.
In the case of Emilio Moya Lledós (1894-1943), moreover, two circumstances kept him from being considered a leading figure: having carried out his professional activity during the Spanish Second Republic, in a profession that, after the Civil War, failed to appreciate the worth of people regardless of their ideology; and, a second reason, having devoted himself almost exclusively to the conservation of architectural heritage rather than to new buildings.
He was the son of the renowned architect Juan Moya Idígoras (1867-1953), and he also belonged to a family with a good number of architects and engineers since the late nineteenth century. All of them, albeit in different ways, were devoted to the craft of building, whether buildings or infrastructure. His commitment to the monument conservation policy of the Republican period, together with his professional and personal friendship with several prominent architects who chose the path of exile, identified him, without nuance, with opposition to the Franco regime, which prevented him from practising his profession and teaching after the Civil War.
In the conservation of monuments, Emilio Moya had as his master, as well as his friend, Leopoldo Torres Balbás, who initiated a new approach. Explained in brief and with regard to construction methods, he used modern materials, especially concrete (a basic material in restoration because it is isotropic, homogeneous and elastic), to mark clearly the part added to the monument, which was, moreover, essential for its stability and conservation.
But perhaps more important is that both architects were part of a broad team of colleagues who, from the Republican Administration or from architectural practice, promoted the cultural goal of making heritage an open and public book of history, while also preventing its indiscriminate sale by its owners, chiefly the Church, the aristocracy and the upper middle class.
In the brief period from 1932 to 1936, Moya restored more than 100 monuments of greater or lesser importance.1 Furthermore, this willingness to conserve what was not significant implied a new consideration of the value2 of the city as heritage, in which the urban landscape is enlivened by the elements that form part of collective memory.
Together with Modesto López Otero, Leopoldo Torres Balbás and Francisco Javier Sánchez Cantón, he formed the group representing Spain at the International Conference of Experts for the Protection and Conservation of Artistic and Historic Monuments, held in Athens in October 1931, which gave rise to the Athens Charter for the Restoration of Historic Monuments, a milestone in the new approach to European restoration.
He worked in private practice briefly, although with some success, as he won several competitions on finishing his degree in 1919. His new-build architecture can be defined by the use of classical elements in cornices, main doors and large windows, while the volumes could be ascribed to the Modern Movement, whose most prominent representatives at the time were his admired teacher López Otero and his colleague Muguruza.
But in 1920, at the age of 25, he won the scholarship to the Academia Española de Bellas Artes in Rome, where he would stay from 1921 to 1926, and which would shape his professional and personal life, as he devoted himself to heritage and married the Milanese Sofía Curiel (Fig. 1). After his period as conservation architect of the 4th Zone – Ávila, Cáceres, Cuenca, Guadalajara, Madrid, Salamanca, Segovia, Toledo and Valladolid (1929-36) – he returned once again to the Academy, but this time as its director (1936-39), appointed in April 1936, after the death of Valle-Inclán, his predecessor as director, and three months before the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War.

The last years of his life were far from peaceful, spent between Madrid and Milan; in both places he faced difficulties: in the former for the reasons already explained, and in the latter because of Mussolini’s anti-Jewish racial laws, which affected the family of his wife, Sofía.3
At the Academia de España in Rome, as a scholarship holder, he coincided with Fernando García Mercadal, Adolfo Blanco Pérez de Camino and other artists. With these two architects he formed a special lifelong friendship, even in difficult times. Almost six years at the Academy, in such a favourable environment and with a well-established programme of systematic study trips throughout Europe and especially Italy, consolidated his knowledge of Heritage and developed drawing as a basic working tool at the service of construction, without thereby losing its artistic value4 (Fig. 2).

Emilio Moya taught at the Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura, first as an assistant lecturer in 1926 and later holding the chair of first-year Design by competitive examination, in 1934.
Drawing architecture in practical classes and on study trips was part of the teaching method, but he would later develop it extensively during his scholarship in Rome and on the trips he made during that period as part of his training5 (Fig. 3).

His interest in vernacular architecture and in the link between constructional tradition and the Modern Movement, which he shared with García Mercadal, led him to collaborate with Giuseppe Pagano, director of Casabella, on the Milan Triennale publication “Architettura rurale italiana”, in August 1936.
To conclude, and returning to the theme of this monographic issue of the journal, in the case of Emilio Moya one more reason for his having been relegated to the category of secondary character is that he was denied the stage of maturity that should have followed, owing to his death at the age of 49.
He also, undoubtedly, lacked the cultural environment and the professional freedom in which he had been trained and had practised his profession, for he died in 1943. But may these lines, and those written by my colleagues in this issue, help to bring out of anonymity and recover figures who can teach us so much through their professional practice and their personal attitude.
And, furthermore, in any case, to show that the role of the secondary characters is fundamental to the effectiveness of the leading ones, just as a cathedral stands out more if it rises from a harmonious and well-preserved village.
Notes
- 1↩
Julián Esteban Chapapría, La conservación del patrimonio español durante la II República (1931-1939). Barcelona: Arquia, 2007. I take this opportunity to thank him for the wealth of data and reflections he provided me with for writing this article and the longer one to be published shortly.
- 2↩
That is to say, and this is worth noting in order to characterise the secondary character of this special issue of the journal VAD, the less significant buildings were also considered objects of conservation despite the scant budget available, which in most cases meant having to settle for their consolidation.
- 3↩
I imagine that our architect, who knew Europe thoroughly, spoke English, German, French and Italian fluently, and had friends and professional contacts in many European countries, must have suffered great disillusionment on living through the Spanish conflict at first hand and then the European conflict in the midst of the Second World War.
- 4↩
Further information can be found in María Díez Ibargoitia’s PhD thesis, “Roma y la formación de los arquitectos en la Academia de España: 1904-1940”, and in the chapter by the same author in the book A Roma/Da Roma, published in 2012.
- 5↩
He filled several dozen personal sketchbooks; his Italian family holds a large collection of them.
How to cite
Moya González, Luis. “Emilio Moya Lledós, arquitecto conservador de la República” [Emilio Moya Lledós, Conservation Architect of the Republic]. VAD. Veredes, arquitectura y divulgación, no. 4 (2020): 115–117.
© 2020 Luis Moya González. CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.